Why Scalia Will Always Matter in American History
My friend James Rosen has marvelously captured the late, great Justice Antonin Scalia in his wonderful new biography SCALIA: RISE TO GREATNESS 1936-1986 (Regnery Books, 2023).
The book is so vivid and timely that the reader feels right from the start as if he has joined a journey or pilgrimage wending toward some kind of grand arrival or validation in the public square.
The sheer eloquence and deep research of the book echoes Scalia’s own such commitments to excellence, and along the way we get to know with sparkling engagement and definitiveness the brilliant manner and route in which one of the most talented, gifted writers and jurists ever to sit on the high court actually got there.
What I particularly loved about the book is that, when finished, I felt as if I genuinely understood how Scalia got to be Scalia — the people, chapters, and vicissitudes of his otherwise busy-life all pouring into the shaping, impacting, and molding of the making of a great American legacy.
This is the best kind of biographical history: fact-based, not-ideological, and willing to tell the truth about the course and nature of human ambition and the application of both power and influence which are not the same thing even though often used interchangeably.
Rosen writes with a brio and crackling energy that is almost tangible, and his personal style carries you along.
He lyrically deduces from the justice’s first 50 years not only everything important about the structure and architecture of ascent to the DC Circuit Court of Appeals and eventually the Supreme Court – star student, life in New York and New Jersey, the ambiance of growing up in a midcentury Italian subculture, Georgetown, Harvard Law, marriage to Maureen (she of Radcliffe), nine children – but also Rosen rightly places the late justice’s Christianity at the center of what unfolds layer by layer, as if a multifoliate rose.
This is a biography of nuance and ballast: the child known as Nino; loving and supportive parents; a brilliant student whose sense of confidence is deep and wide as oceans; setbacks here and there in often unexpected and complicated ways; the balancing of family and work; teaching law and the founding of the Federalist Society, a gift for navigating Washington DC and its diffuse power structure; the selection and nomination by President Ronald Reagan to a seat on the Supreme Court; and the unanimous vote of confirmation in the Senate. All of it is fascinating and even riveting, packed into 400+ pages, and with a second volume ahead.
Yet for all the welcomed-details and hairpin curves, what is best about this biography is that the golden narrative does not miss at any remove Scalia’s two major animating commitments beyond family: his deep and profound faith in God, and his unwavering fidelity to the United States Constitution. The latter commitment made him probably the most famous originalist in American history, and the seedlings of that tenacious jurisprudence, for all that would follow on the high court, have been planted beautifully in this biography.
But it is the former commitment, to Scalia’s profound and personal faith, that I particularly enjoyed reading and learning about. Time and again, I was struck by the centrality of his Catholicism and the subsequent timeless and personal honor code that was shaped by it.
I remember a famous interview the justice did late in his life in which the topic of the reality of the devil came up. The journalist asking the questions of Scalia seemed semi-surprised that Scalia actually believed in a literal devil, while Scalia expressed mild-amusement that the journalist seemed not to understand that the overwhelming majority of Americans believed in the devil — just as he did. This kind of authenticity of faith is a revelatory pillar in Rosen’s fine book.
I came away certain that it would be impossible to understand Scalia without understanding his faith, and Rosen has succeeded in evoking that faith in a manner subtle, supple, and nimble in a way rarely achieved in biographies about famous Americans. Too often, faith gets a short shrift. Not here.
It brought to mind one of the most beautiful eulogies I have ever been honored to hear: the one delivered by his son Father Paul Scalia at the Shrine of the Immaculate Conception in Washington DC for his father:
“We are gathered here because of one man. A man known personally to many of us, known only by reputation to even more. A man loved by many, scored by others. A man known for great controversy, and for great compassion. That man, of course, is Jesus of Nazareth.”
Father Scalia was humbly reminding us that Christ and faith were the center of his father’s life, and not the things of this world — fascinating and marvelous though they may be. The trappings of the court did not change Scalia; he changed it and its reputation.
Rosen in his fine biography makes the same distinction, earning the late Justice Scalia his perfect biographer.
’Tis the season for holiday reading!
Check out Daily Citizen’s cheery winter reads.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Tim Goeglein champions God’s welcomed role in the public square. His years of public service and private initiative have been devoted to faith, freedom, and family. Tim is the Vice President for External and Government Relations at Focus on the Family in Washington DC. He served in high-level government posts for two decades. He worked as Special Assistant to President George W. Bush, where he was the Deputy Director of the White House Office of Public Liaison from 2001 to 2008. He was the President’s principal outreach contact for conservatives, think tanks, veteran’s groups, faith-based groups, and some of America’s leading cultural organizations. He was a member of the President’s original 2000 campaign and White House staff, serving for nearly 8 years. Also, he has served as a senior fellow at The Heritage Foundation and a professor of government at Liberty University. Goeglein is the author of the political memoir THE MAN IN THE MIDDLE: FAITH AND POLITICS IN THE GEORGE W. BUSH ERA (B and H Books) which was published in September, 2011. His second book is AMERICAN RESTORATION: HOW FAITH, FAMILY, AND PERSONAL SACRIFICE CAN HEAL OUR NATION (Regnery, 2019), in which he offers a roadmap to national and spiritual renewal by examining American culture. His new book is TOWARD A MORE PERFECT UNION: THE MORAL AND CULTURAL CASE FOR TEACHING THE GREAT AMERICAN STORY (Fidelis Books, 2023). From 1988 through 1998, Tim was the Deputy Press Secretary, and then Press Secretary and Communications Director, for U.S. Senator Dan Coats of Indiana (who was in the Senate for a decade). Between his time with the Senate and Bush campaign, Tim served as Communications Director for Gary Bauer in his presidential bid. Tim was an intern for then-U.S. Senator Dan Quayle in 1985, and for then-Representative Dan Coats and for NBC News in 1986, during his college years at Indiana University’s Ernie Pyle School of Journalism. When he graduated in 1986, he was the Richard Gray Fellow in his senior year. Tim’s first job upon graduation was as a television news producer for the NBC affiliate in his hometown of Fort Wayne, Indiana. During high school and college, he produced a show for WOWO Radio, then owned by the Westinghouse Broadcasting Corporation. The program was heard in 28 states. Tim holds Honorary Doctorate degrees from Concordia University, New York City; and from Faith Evangelical College and Seminary, Tacoma, Washington. Tim is the secretary of the Coalitions for America board, a member of the board for the National Civic Art Society, a member of the board of Family Policy Alliance, and a member of the board of governors of the Young America’s Foundation which owns and operates the Ronald Reagan Ranch in Santa Barbara, California. Tim also serves on the Institute for American Universities Advisory Board. Goeglein served as Board Secretary of the American Conservative Union Foundation. Also, he is a member of the Council for National Policy, the Philadelphia Society, and the Capitol Hill Club. Tim serves on the Sanctity of Life Commission for his church body, the 2.5 million-member Lutheran Church-Missouri Synod; is a board member of The Lutheran Center for Religious Liberty; and has served as a deacon in his church in northern Virginia for 30 years. His hobbies include reading, tennis, swimming, biking, and the fine arts. The most important thing to know about Tim is that he is married to the love of his life, Jenny, of 31 years, and they have two sons Tim and Paul -- one in public policy and one in the fine arts and music.
Related Posts
Disney (Sort of) Wakes Up: Parents Are Boss!
December 20, 2024
Superman and a Culture in Need of Masculinity
December 20, 2024
Child Corrects First Lady Jill Biden: ‘Happy Christmas!’
December 19, 2024
Mangione Defense Fund Inexplicably Passes $150K
December 19, 2024