New York Legislature Passes Bill Requiring Social Media Warning Labels

It’s no secret websites like Instagram, TikTok, Snapchat and Facebook have a chokehold on America’s youth. That’s why New York lawmakers have passed a bill requiring social media platforms to display mental health warning labels to in-state users.

Senate Bill S405 cites a June 2024 statement from U.S. Surgeon General Vivek Murthy, calling for warning labels on “addictive” platforms:

Requiring social media apps with certain particularly noxious design features to display warning labels to all users at the point of user access … is a reasonable and necessary step to take for consumer health and safety.

The legislation references Surgeon General Murthy’s characterization of the current youth mental crisis as a “public health emergency,” and cites various evidence to support this claim:

Research shows that social media exposure overstimulates reward centers, creating pathways comparable to those of an individual experiencing substance abuse or gambling addictions.
Leaked company documents reveal that social media companies knew that compulsive use of their products was also associated with “loss of analytical skills, memory formation, contextual thinking, conversational depth, (and) empathy.”
Among female adolescent users, the association between poor mental health and social media use is now stronger than the association between poor mental health and binge drinking, obesity, or hard drug use.

Additionally, the bill included several statistics supporting the correlation between social media and poor mental health:

  • As of 2023, 12 – 15-year-olds spend an average of 4.8 hours on social media platforms.
  • Today, almost half of adolescents report social media makes them feel worse about their bodies.
  • Teens with the highest levels of social media use are twice as likely to rate their mental health as either “poor” or “very poor.”
  • From 2008 – 2015, the percentage of hospital visits among adolescent social media users nearly doubled due to suicidal ideation or attempts.
  • From 2011 – 2018, self-poisonings among 10 – 12-year-old girls quadrupled.
  • From 2011 – 2018, suicide rates among 10 – 14-year-old girls doubled, and hospital admissions for self-harm tripled.

State Assemblywoman Nily Rozic, a sponsor for the New York bill, commented:

By requiring clear warning labels, we’re giving families the tools to understand the risks and pushing tech companies to take responsibility for the impact of their design choices.
It’s time we prioritize mental health over engagement metrics.

Additionally, Jim Steyer, Common Sense Media Founder and CEO, stated:

We owe it to families to provide clear, evidence-based information about the consequences of excessive use.
When we learned alcohol could cause birth defects, we added warning labels for pregnant women. When nicotine was linked to cancer, we labeled every cigarette pack.
It’s time we took the same approach to social media – the latest addictive product that has kids hooked.

Last week, Senate Bill S4505 was passed in the New York Assembly and Senate. It is currently awaiting the signature of New York’s governor, Kathy Hochul, who previously signed bills prohibiting social media platforms from exposing teens to “addictive” algorithmic content without parental consent. 

If passed, New York will join other states that have or are attempting to issue warnings on social media apps, including Minnesota, Texas, Colorado and California.

Social media platforms have opposed New York’s potential bill, arguing that requiring warning labels on their websites would violate their rights to free speech.

Specifically, NetChoice’s Amy Bos, director of state and federal affairs, recently stated:

The proposed legislation constitutes an unprecedented expansion of government power that would compel private companies to espouse the state’s preferred messaging, a clear violated of the First Amendment’s protection against compelled speech.

However, warning labels on products proven to be harmful do not violate free speech. Rather, they serve to promote truth and transparency by notifying adolescents of the risks associated with social media use.

In a world where internet reliance is ever-increasing, it is crucial for the next generation to be fully informed about the information that constructs and influences their daily lives.

Related Articles and Resources:

‘The Tech Exit’ Helps Families Ditch Addictive Tech – For Good.

New York Prepares to Restrict School Smartphone Use

Social Psychologist Finds Smartphones and Social Media Harm Kids in These Four Ways

Four Ways to Protect Your Kids from Bad Tech, From Social Psychologist Jonathan Haidt

‘Big Tech’ Device Designs Dangerous for Kids, Research Finds

Surgeon General Recommends Warning on Social Media Platforms