Allie Beth Stuckey Debates Progressive Christians with Grace and Truth
Allie Beth Stuckey gave a master class in Christian apologetics earlier this week, defending some of the most controversial conservative positions of our day with grace and truth.
Her debate on “Surrounded” has gone viral with over 1.7 million views. If you are a conservative Christian, it is a must-see.
For an hour and 40 minutes, Stuckey debated five different topics with 20 progressive self-described Christians. Topics ranged from God’s design for marriage, abortion, toxic empathy that leads to sin, progressivism, and whether the church’s position on homosexuality causes “damage and suffering to gay people.”
“Surrounded” is produced by Jubilee Media. The series pits one notable figure against a group of 20 opponents. People literally sit in a circle around the featured person sitting at a debate table and jump into debate when given the opportunity.
The guest typically make several claims, while those opposing side take turns debating or challenging the position. When members of the group feel that the person currently debating isn’t strong or fair in their arguments, they can raise a red flag to end that person’s turn and another individual can take a turn in the debate chair.
Charlie Kirk, Lila Rose, Michael Knowles, Ben Shapiro and Jordan Peterson include other nnotable conservative individuals featured on “Surrounded.”
According to Stuckey, the episode was recorded shortly after Charlie Kirk’s death and she almost canceled the debate. Her last real conversation with Kirk included receiving advice on how to approach the debate.
I wanted to cancel this debate, because it was right after Charlie died and the day before his memorial. But then I remembered that this was the last real conversation CK and I had. He was such a good friend.
— Allie Beth Stuckey (@conservmillen) October 9, 2025
I took your advice, Charlie. Thanks for everything. https://t.co/tSMUnJaZzF pic.twitter.com/VCNRwL1nY0
Stuckey also shared feeling the presence of the Holy Spirit during the debate. It was recorded the day before Kirk’s memorial and even the producers, who Stuckey says are progressive, felt a difference in the tone. Stuckey credits Jesus and thanked Charlie for coaching her and playing a part in honoring Jesus through the debate.
What you don’t see in the published version of this debate is my first opponent approaching me and saying, “I’m so sorry about your friend Charlie.”
— Allie Beth Stuckey (@conservmillen) October 13, 2025
It was the day before his memorial. This sincere gesture set the tone.
I had already made it my aim to disarm them with… https://t.co/C3g0oZEHAw
Here are more viral moments in Stuckey’s debate.
Watch @conservmillen absolutely shred the pro-abortion argument that abortion is non-violent (and stick around to watch her shred the anti-Biblical idea that life begins at first breath) pic.twitter.com/Nu83c7iu2S
— Ben Shapiro (@benshapiro) October 12, 2025
The idea that murdering children before they’re born is somehow better than them being raised poor or in bad circumstances will always be sickening to me.
— Natalie Jean Beisner (@NJBeisner) October 13, 2025
Do these people not hear themselves when they say that?
You have the opportunity to make something good out of bad… pic.twitter.com/e0UF0qk2Sk
Allie does a great job here of defining and defending a biblical view of marriage. And you'll notice she doesn't have to compromise to be kind. Well done, @conservmillen. pic.twitter.com/K93SF8VsyN
— Seth Dillon (@SethDillon) October 12, 2025
You were created on purpose, by a God who makes no mistakes.
— Riley Gaines (@Riley_Gaines_) October 12, 2025
The kindest thing you can do for someone believing they were born in the wrong body is remind them of that truth. @conservmillen is fantastic here.
"Love never rejoices in wrongdoing, but rejoices with the truth." pic.twitter.com/eNNw3F1veq
One of the things I appreciate about Allie in this clip is she isn’t trying to DESTROY the person she’s speaking to.
— Samuel Sey (@SlowToWrite) October 12, 2025
She is trying to persuade him.
As Allie suggests, toxic empathy will make you more sensitive to a sinner’s feelings about sin than God’s feelings about that sin. pic.twitter.com/z3sseEh83k
Well done, Allie Beth Stuckey, for modeling how to engage faithfully with a culture that often rejects a conservative Christian worldview. She defended Christian teaching without hostility, held firm to her beliefs without arrogance and spoke with grace even under fire.
In a time when many believers feel cultural pressure to water down their biblical convictions, Stuckey represents exactly what it means to stand your ground. She represented a Christian worldview that does not drift depending on the cultural norms but is anchored in the truth of the Bible.
Stuckey reminded all of us that it is not only possible to represent our Christian worldview in a hostile environment, but it is extremely powerful when it is unashamedly executed with grace and truth.
Watch the entire debate here.
Image credit: Jubilee/YouTube
ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Nicole Hunt, J.D., is an attorney and serves as a writer and spokesperson at Focus on the Family. She provides analysis and advocacy engagement for Christians to promote faith, family, and freedom. Some of the issues she writes and speaks on include life, religious freedom, parental rights, marriage, and gender. Prior to joining Focus on the Family, Nicole practiced employment law specifically advising businesses and ministries on employment policies and practices. Nicole worked in Washington, D.C. as a Legislative Assistant to two Members of Congress. During her time on Capitol Hill, Nicole provided policy analysis and voting recommendations to Members of Congress on a variety of public policy matters, wrote speeches, drafted committee statements and questions, wrote floor statements, produced legislation and amendments to legislation, met and developed networks with constituents and interest groups, and worked on regional projects. In addition, Nicole served as an intern to Former Attorney General Ed Meese in the Center for Legal and Judicial Studies at the Heritage Foundation, provided legal analysis to Americans United for Life, and interned in the Office of Strategic Initiatives at The White House during the George W. Bush Administration. Nicole earned her J.D. from George Mason University Antonin Scalia Law School and her Bachelor of Arts in Philosophy and Political Science from Westmont College. Nicole enjoys riding horses and spending time camping and hiking with her family in the great outdoors. Nicole is married to her husband, Jeff, and they have four children. Follow Nicole on Twitter @nicolehunt
Related Posts

Katy Faust’s 7 Ways to Spend a Billion Dollars
December 2, 2025

Supreme Court To Hear Evangelist’s Religious Freedom Case
December 2, 2025

Vatican Reaffirms: Marriage is Between One Man and One Woman
December 1, 2025
