XX-XY Athletics, Christian Bookstore and Parent Groups Appear Before Court to Challenge Radical ‘Trans’ Law

On Monday, November 16, a federal appeals court in Denver heard arguments in three lawsuits challenging Colorado’s radical “trans” law.

The plaintiffs, including a Colorado Springs-based Christian bookstore, XX-XY Athletics and Protect Kids Colorado, are asking the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals to stop Colorado from enforcing the new law while their cases move forward.

Background

In May 2025 Colorado lawmakers passed HB 25-1312. The law changed the Colorado Anti-Discrimination Act (CADA) so that “gender expression” includes a person’s chosen name and how the person chooses to be addressed.

The law requires places of public accommodation, like bookstores and businesses, to use preferred pronouns or face claims of discrimination.

As reported by the Daily Citizen, Focus on the Family spoke out against the bill, citing concerns about free speech and religious freedom.

Jim Daly, Focus on the Family President, spoke against the measure online, and representatives from the organization testified against the bill.

Two groups have filed lawsuits against the Colorado law.

Defending Education, Colorado Parent Advocacy Network, Protect Kids Colorado and Do No Harm have filed a lawsuit together with the law firm Consovoy McCarthy.

XX-XY Athletics, a pro-woman sports apparel company founded by Jennifer Sey, and Born Again Used Books are both represented by Alliance Defending Freedom.

Recent Legal Action

Both groups have requested a preliminary injunction to keep the state from enforcing the law against them while the litigation proceeds.

In February, the Daily Citizen reported, the magistrate judge recommended against a preliminary injunction and in March the district judge denied it.

Interestingly, in September the same judge declined a motion to dismiss the case, as requested by the state, because of “a very real possibility” that the state could enforce the law against the businesses. 

On Monday, the court heard arguments appealing the lower court’s decision to deny injunctive relief to the parties.

After the hearing, plaintiffs in the case held a press conference and reiterated their commitment to speaking the truth.

Jennifer Sey and XX-XY Athletics:

Born Again Used Books:

Protect Kids Colorado:

Impact

This case is about much more than pronouns. It’s about whether Coloradans can speak freely according to their conscience, in line with biological reality and without fear of the state punishing their speech.

The court gave no timeline for their decision. They could order an injunction, send the case back to the lower court or let the denial stand.

Even if the denial of the preliminary injunction stands, the lawsuit will continue to be litigated based on the merits of the case.

The Daily Citizen will continue to follow this developing story.

Related articles and resources:

Christian Bookstore Sues Colorado Over Radical ‘Trans’ Law

Oppose Colorado’s Radical Abortion and ‘Transgender Rights’ Legislation

Speaking Out Against Lies, Colorado HB 1312 Testimonies

Update on Lawsuits Challenging Colorado’s Radical ‘Trans’ Law

Photo from YouTube.