Gertrude Himmelfarb – The Best Friend Unwavering Moral Standards Ever Had

Gertrude Himmelfarb has died. She was 97. She was among a handful of the most important scholars ever of Victorian England, and of its major intellectuals, political figures, religious figures and literary persons of that remarkable span of time that occurred during Queen Victoria’s long reign in the 19th century.
But Himmelfarb’s particular importance and relevance was not only the scholarship of that vivid period of British history but also its moral and social code-application to what the United States was becoming after the social and moral revolution of the 1960s and 70s. That was the era when the Judeo-Christian moral standards in marriage, family, parenting, general social norms and timeless standards of right and wrong were routinely and frontally assaulted and undermined by an astringent moral relativism that sought to crash the concept of stability and continuity.
Himmelfarb, who as a young woman had been a serious student of Karl Marx and tended leftward in social policy, came to see that the Victorians’ virtues and values provided the kinds of guardrails that made for a healthy, confident and vibrant moral ecology. Himmelfarb was Jewish, and she had a lot of respect and regard for American evangelicals who refused to alter or sublimate core moral convictions and conventions in an era when situational ethics and the broad breakdown of the most vital institution, the family, seemed to go hand in hand, and be in overdrive.
The virtues she admired in the Victorians – hard work, self-respect and self-reliance, timeless values about good and evil, right and wrong – were ones she felt Americans of the 20th and 21st centuries could benefit from and emulate as always-relevant and always-timely.
“For Victorians,” she wrote, “these virtues were fixed and certain. They were the standards against which behavior could and should be measured … When conduct fell short of those standards, it was judged in moral terms as bad, wrong, or evil – not, as is more often the case today, as misguided, undesirable, or (the most recent corruption of the moral vocabulary) ‘inappropriate.’”
She sensed “a grievous moral disorder” following the uproar of the 1960s – not only President Lyndon Johnson’s Great Society and its impact on families, marriage and America’s urban core and poverty – but also the damaging loss of the search for truth and the making of good citizens which had been the reason and purpose of American education, and now under direct assault on far too many American campuses and in classrooms.
She enjoyed a great and long marriage to Irving Kristol, one of the founders of what became known as neoconservatism, and for many years, her husband was far better known as a public intellectual and magazine editor, author, and lecturer. As the years pass – Irving died in 2009 – it is Himmelfarb’s scholarship on the Victorians and its importance for today that emerges as important and applicable as ever. She often wrote about the need for a “re-moralization” of America and the West. She was prescient, and she was right.
She told a journalist in 1995: “Virtues are very hard. Vices are easy to come by. Once young people had the leisure and money to indulge themselves, it was almost inevitable that they do it.” Just so.
I was honored to have met her, and spent two sustained, remarkable hours with her in 2003 in vigorous conversation and dialogue. She was deeply concerned about identity politics and decreasing standards in literature on campuses and in higher learning. She was particularly concerned that elites in America had, by and large, given up on any felt need or sense of personal responsibility for standards and ethics that she felt they were duty-bound to uphold, model and champion.
It was an echo of a statement she had made more than a decade earlier: “Self-discipline is important for the upper classes, especially today in an affluent, consumerist, very highly individualistic society, where it is so easy to be self-indulgent materially, morally, and sexually. It is very important for the working classes and should be for what is now called the underclass.”
Gertrude Himmelfarb was a gifted public intellectual and commanding prose stylist; a writer of many important books and essays; and overall, she was in the front ranks of scholars and moralists who will still matter a hundred years from now. Her scholarship and voice in the public square will be deeply missed because the narrative of her professional life and vocation never mattered more than now — a true testament to her great mind and great heart.
’Tis the season for holiday reading!
Check out Daily Citizen’s cheery winter reads.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Tim Goeglein champions God’s welcomed role in the public square. His years of public service and private initiative have been devoted to faith, freedom, and family. Tim is the Vice President for External and Government Relations at Focus on the Family in Washington DC. He served in high-level government posts for two decades. He worked as Special Assistant to President George W. Bush, where he was the Deputy Director of the White House Office of Public Liaison from 2001 to 2008. He was the President’s principal outreach contact for conservatives, think tanks, veteran’s groups, faith-based groups, and some of America’s leading cultural organizations. He was a member of the President’s original 2000 campaign and White House staff, serving for nearly 8 years. Also, he has served as a senior fellow at The Heritage Foundation and a professor of government at Liberty University. Goeglein is the author of the political memoir THE MAN IN THE MIDDLE: FAITH AND POLITICS IN THE GEORGE W. BUSH ERA (B and H Books) which was published in September, 2011. His second book is AMERICAN RESTORATION: HOW FAITH, FAMILY, AND PERSONAL SACRIFICE CAN HEAL OUR NATION (Regnery, 2019), in which he offers a roadmap to national and spiritual renewal by examining American culture. His new book is TOWARD A MORE PERFECT UNION: THE MORAL AND CULTURAL CASE FOR TEACHING THE GREAT AMERICAN STORY (Fidelis Books, 2023). From 1988 through 1998, Tim was the Deputy Press Secretary, and then Press Secretary and Communications Director, for U.S. Senator Dan Coats of Indiana (who was in the Senate for a decade). Between his time with the Senate and Bush campaign, Tim served as Communications Director for Gary Bauer in his presidential bid. Tim was an intern for then-U.S. Senator Dan Quayle in 1985, and for then-Representative Dan Coats and for NBC News in 1986, during his college years at Indiana University’s Ernie Pyle School of Journalism. When he graduated in 1986, he was the Richard Gray Fellow in his senior year. Tim’s first job upon graduation was as a television news producer for the NBC affiliate in his hometown of Fort Wayne, Indiana. During high school and college, he produced a show for WOWO Radio, then owned by the Westinghouse Broadcasting Corporation. The program was heard in 28 states. Tim holds Honorary Doctorate degrees from Concordia University, New York City; and from Faith Evangelical College and Seminary, Tacoma, Washington. Tim is the secretary of the Coalitions for America board, a member of the board for the National Civic Art Society, a member of the board of Family Policy Alliance, and a member of the board of governors of the Young America’s Foundation which owns and operates the Ronald Reagan Ranch in Santa Barbara, California. Tim also serves on the Institute for American Universities Advisory Board. Goeglein served as Board Secretary of the American Conservative Union Foundation. Also, he is a member of the Council for National Policy, the Philadelphia Society, and the Capitol Hill Club. Tim serves on the Sanctity of Life Commission for his church body, the 2.5 million-member Lutheran Church-Missouri Synod; is a board member of The Lutheran Center for Religious Liberty; and has served as a deacon in his church in northern Virginia for 30 years. His hobbies include reading, tennis, swimming, biking, and the fine arts. The most important thing to know about Tim is that he is married to the love of his life, Jenny, of 31 years, and they have two sons Tim and Paul -- one in public policy and one in the fine arts and music.
Related Posts

The Cultural Paradox of Following Jesus Christ
November 21, 2024

C.S. Lewis and Answers to the Problem of Pain
November 20, 2024

Why Believe in Christianity? Because it is True.
September 20, 2024

Christianity is Both a Religion and a Relationship
January 19, 2024